In 2025, nearly three out of ten Italian families cut back on the quantity or quality of their food to make ends meet: 29.4%, according to Istat. This is a sign that eating well seems like a luxury. The data was discussed today at the Milan Civic Aquarium during the 16th edition of the Human & Green Retail Forum, organized by NDB – Il Marketing Consapevole and PLEF – Planet Life Economy Foundation, in collaboration with the news website Green Retail News—tell a different story.
The Possible Cart
The Mediterranean Algorithm, developed by NDB and NielsenIQ, compared the household food purchases of a sample of 18,000 families between 2024 and 2026 with a shopping cart based on CREA’s Guidelines for Healthy Eating. For the same number of calories, choosing the most affordable alternatives in each food group would result in a shopping basket that is 22% cheaper and has a 28% smaller carbon footprint. These are potential results, but they indicate a tangible margin for improvement.
“The Mediterranean Algorithm is the first tool built on the actual purchasing habits of Italian households that allows retailers to tailor their product assortment, prices, and promotions toward shopping with a smaller environmental footprint and greater nutritional balance,” says Domenico Canzoniero, founder of NDB – Il Marketing Consapevole. “This opens up the opportunity to combine sustainability and affordability by working on the composition of the shopping cart over time. A balanced diet, a reduced environmental footprint, and affordability are the three objectives that give concrete form to the food transition. Based on these, we will measure annually the sustainability of Italians’ grocery spending and the effectiveness of the actions retailers take to make the best choice also the easiest one.”
Hidden Emissions in the Supply Chain
Why supermarkets, of all places? Because the bulk of their impact isn’t visible at the point of sale. According to the Carbon Trust, nearly 85% of the emissions from the world’s ten largest chains stem from production and other stages of the supply chain for the products they sell, yet six of them lack detailed plans to promote lower-emission farming practices. In Italy, ISPRA estimates that food accounts for about 47% of the environmental footprint of consumer spending, and red meat alone accounts for 26% of the emissions associated with grocery shopping.
“Large-scale retail serves as a vital link between the worlds of production and consumption. It is in this position that it can play a decisive role in addressing two major challenges of our time: the climate crisis and the protection of public health,” explains Paolo Mamo, president of PLEF. “Decisions regarding suppliers, product assortments, prices, and promotions affect the environmental impact of supply chains and the eating habits of millions of people. The ecological transition must therefore be integrated into retailers’ economic strategies through concrete commitments and measurable results. There must also be shared responsibility with public institutions, which are called upon to create the conditions that ensure the most sustainable choices are accessible to everyone.”
The bookshelf is not neutral
There is also room for improvement in terms of quality. A study by the European Commission’s Joint Research Center on more than 180,000 packaged products in 21 countries found significant differences in sugar, salt, and fat content within the same product category: in breakfast cereals, sugar content ranges from 1 to 28 grams per 100 grams. In England, starting in 2022, certain products high in fat, sugar, or salt will be banned from store entrances, checkout counters, and aisle ends, and as of October 2025, they will also be excluded from “3-for-2” promotions.
Measuring What You Buy
The issue of verification remains. Accordingto GS1 Italy’s “Osservatorio Immagino,” 85.1% of products sold in large-scale retail have at least one claim related to environmental sustainability on their labels. But a claim does not measure impact, and the new European regulations against greenwashing require verifiable data. For this reason, PLEF and NDB, through the Human&Green Retail Experience project, have proposed to the Ministry of the Environment and Energy Security that aggregated sales data be used to track the nutritional quality and environmental footprint of actual purchases over time. The true test isn’t the promises—it’s the receipt.
